Botanical Medicines for Treatment of Fibromyalgia
Eric Yarnell, ND and Lauren Russel, ND
Fibromyalgia is a multifactorial syndrome diagnosed on the basis of clinical symptoms with no known clinical markers or lab tests pointing to a definitive diagnosis. The most common symptoms are nonrestorative sleep, fatigue, chronic widespread tenderness of joints and tissues, headache, decreased memory and concentration, and personality changes.
While studies have failed to identify a specific underlying cause, fibromyalgia has often been associated with irritable bowel symptoms, paresthesias and depression (Bengtsson, 2002). More than 80% of patients are female, with a mean age of onset of 45 years of age. Treatment is frequently symptom-oriented and palliative, with conventional therapy focusing on low-dose anti-depressants and analgesics.
Botanical medicine offers a significant potential benefit to fibromyalgia patients, though surprisingly little research has been done in the area. The major classes of herbs relevant to fibromyalgia patients are analgesics, adaptogens, antioxidants, counter-irritants and nervines.
Capsicum spp (Cayenne)
Fibromyalgia patients are often treated as though they are malingering because they present with pain disproportionate to what is observed clinically, but this is not the case. Dysregulation of pain-processing mechanisms is a possible cause of the allodynia and sensitivity experienced by these patients. The idea of using cayenne topically for pain is an old one. Eclectic physician Harvey Wickes Felter described capsicum as an important “topical stimulant, rubefacient and counter-irritant” that, “by its revulsive action … often relieves local pain.” He added that, “either the tincture painted upon the part or the capsicum plaster may give relief to so-called chronic rheumatic pains, and be applied to lumbago, pleurodynia and intercostal neuralgia” (Felter, 1922).
As is well-known, Capsicum spp contains capsaicin, a lipophilic molecule that acts as a topical analgesic shown in multiple double-blind clinical trials to reduce neuropathic pain and ease musculoskeletal disorders (Kingery, 1997; Keitel, 2001; McCarthy and McCarty, 1992; Mason, 2004).
In a double-blind, placebo-controlled trial involving 45 patients with fibromyalgia, 0.025% capsaicin cream applied to tender points was shown to significantly reduce tenderness and increase grip strength (McCarty, 1994). There were no statistically significant differences in overall pain. The most commonly reported adverse event from the study was intermittent burning or stinging at the site of application. Another trial of 23 patients with chronic neck pain demonstrated decreased subjective neck pain when capsaicin 0.025% cream was applied four times a day for up to five weeks (Mathias, 1995). Tincture of cayenne added to any base cream works just as well as isolated capsaicin. Frequent application is most effective, which can limit the utility of this treatment for anything beyond acute flare-ups.
When applied topically, capsaicin binds to vanillinoid receptors in pain- and itch-sensing neurons in the skin, causing an initial period of neuronal excitation and sensitivity through the release of substance P from sensory fibers. This initial stage of sensitivity is experienced as itching or burning and accompanied by cutaneous vasodilation (Mason, 2004). What follows is a refractory period in which sensitivity diminishes and substance P is depleted and its synthesis is blocked. Repeated applications increase the pain threshold by causing long-lasting yet reversible desensitization of the neuronal cell membrane.
Antioxidants
Some research suggests that a number of fibromyalgia symptoms stem from poor peripheral and cerebral circulation. Therefore, increasing venoprotective anthocyanidin flavonoid intake makes sense as a possible treatment. In one randomized, placebo-controlled crossover trial, 12 patients with fibromyalgia received four different treatments, each for 12 weeks with a one-week washout period between treatments (Edwards, 2000). Study participants rotated through receiving 40, 80 or 120mg of anthocyanidins and placebo, and were allowed to continue other prescribed treatments for fibromyalgia. The anthocyanidins were extracted from Vitis vinifera (European grape) seed, Vaccinium myrtillus (bilberry) fruit and Vaccinium macrocarpon (cranberry) fruit. At the end of the trial, participants were assessed for trigger point tenderness, secretory IgA levels and IBS symptoms. Of the nine participants who completed the trial, a small but significant effect was noticed as compared to placebo for sleep disturbance and severity of fatigue. The optimum effect was seen with an 80mg per day dose and a minimum therapeutic trial of three months.
One of the late Dr. Bill Mitchell’s favorite remedies for the treatment of fibromyalgia is well known to naturopathic physicians – Silybum marianum (milk thistle) (Miitchell, 2003). Besides its well-known benefits on the liver and kidney, milk thistle is, of course, also significantly antioxidant.
Ginkgo biloba is another herb that has demonstrated potent antioxidant activity in studies, with a low incidence of side effects. One open, uncontrolled trial found that 80mg of Ginkgo standardized extract with 200mg coenzyme Q10 over a period of 84 days improved quality of life (Lister, 2002). More rigorous studies are warranted.
Adaptogens
Adaptogens can be used effectively in the treatment of patients with fibromyalgia because they address the disordered response of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis that research suggests is a possible cause. Adaptogens help patients cope with and resist stress, another factor in the development of this syndrome. None have been subjected to clinical trials in the area of fibromyalgia. The choice of adaptogen depends on the individual factors the patient presents with balanced against ecological factors (that is, choosing the most local resource possible and avoiding endangered species). This topic has been covered previously in this column (April 2006 NDNR).
Nervines
Nervines are herbs that calm the nervous system, relax spasms and decrease pain (Abascal and Yarnell, 2004). Though untested in fibromyalgia patients, clinically they often can bring some measure of pain relief and reduce anxiety. Among the many bioregional options are Valeriana sitchensis (Pacific valerian) from the Northwest, Eschscholzia californica (California poppy) from California, Scutellaria lateriflora (skullcap) from the East, Argemone mexicana (prickly poppy) from the Southwest or Piper methysticum (kava) from Oceania.
Another interesting remedy with some nervine properties is Actaea racemosa (black cohosh), a member of the buttercup or Ranunculaceae family and a cousin of Pulsatilla spp (pasque flower, anemone), an herb with which it has much in common and which is an even more potent anodyne. While most practitioners use black cohosh as an estrogen modulator and uterine tonic, it is also spasmolytic, inflammation modulating, analgesic and antirheumatic. Black cohosh was used by the Eclectics in the treatment of myalgia, neuralgia, reproductive disorders and rheumatic conditions. According to HW Felter, “Macrotys [as it was then known] was introduced into Eclectic medicine by King in 1844 as a remedy for acute rheumatism and neuralgia with such success that it gradually came to be a leading medicine for these disorders” (Felter, 1922). Native Americans used the roots and rhizomes to treat rheumatism as well as menstrual problems.
There are many safe and effective botanical remedies available for the treatment of fibromyalgia, despite the limited research. Additional studies are needed to determine effective doses and provide alternatives to the many pharmaceutical options currently being proposed in the literature. Botanical medicine has much to offer patients with this debilitating condition.
Eric Yarnell, ND is a graduate of Bastyr University. He completed a two-year residency with Silena Heron, ND, and served as chair of botanical medicine at SCNM. He is past senior editor of the Journal of Naturopathic Medicine. Dr. Yarnell is a founding member and current president of the Botanical Medicine Academy and author of numerous textbooks and articles, including Naturopathic Urology and Men’s Health, Naturopathic Gastroenterology and Clinical Botanical Medicine. His area of clinical focus is urology and men’s health. He is assistant professor in botanical medicine at Bastyr University.
Lauren Russel, ND is a graduate of Bastyr University, currently focusing on therapies for cancer and endocrine disorders. She has been a medical writer and editor for many years, with numerous publications to her name.
References
Abascal K, Yarnell E: Nervine herbs for treating anxiety, Altern Complemen Ther 10(6):309-15, 2004.
Bengtsson A: The muscle in fibromyalgia, Rheumatology 41:721-4, 2002.
Edwards AM et al: Food supplements in the treatment of primary fibromyalgia: A double-blind, crossover trial of anthocyanidins and placebo, Journal of Nutritional and Environmental Medicine 10(3):189-99, 2000.
Felter HW: Eclectic Materia Medica, Pharmacology and Therapeutics. Sandy, 1922 (reprinted 1998), Eclectic Medical Publications.
Keitel W et al: Capsicum pain plaster in chronic non-specific low back pain, Arzneimittelforschung 51(11): 896-903, 2001.
Kingery WS: A critical review of controlled clinical trials for peripheral neuropathic pain and complex regional pain syndromes, Pain 73(2);123-39, 1997.
Lister RE: An open, pilot study to evaluate the potential benefits of coenzyme Q10 combined with Ginkgo biloba extract in fibromyalgia syndrome, J Int Med Res 30(2):195-9, 2002.
Mathias BJ et al: Topical capsaicin for chronic neck pain: A pilot study, Am J Phys Med Rehabil 74(1):39-44, 1995.
Mason L et al: Systematic review of topical capsaicin for the treatment of chronic pain, BMJ 238:991, 2004.
McCarthy GM, McCarty DJ: Effect of topical capsaicin in the therapy of painful osteoarthritis of the hands, J Rheumatol 19(4):604-7, 1992.
McCarty DJ et al: Treatment of pain due to fibromyalgia with topical capsaicin: A pilot study, Semin Arth Rheum 23:41-7, 1994.
Mitchell W: Plant Medicine in Practice. St. Louis, 2003, Churchill Livingstone.
