Kfar Saba Syndrome

 In Autoimmune/Allergy Medicine, Endocrinology, Gastrointestinal, Mind/Body

Jacob Schor, ND, FABNO

I’ve seen three cases of ”Kfar Saba Syndrome” in as many weeks. Don’t go rushing off to look up this condition in your Merck Manual; it’s not listed. It’s my own name for the triad hypothyroidism, iron deficiency and B12 deficiency in the same patient. It happens more often than you might guess.

Kfar Saba is a city northeast of Tel Aviv on the way to Nabulus. In Hebrew it means something like grandfather’s village.” My name for it has little to do with this condition. Back in 2006, the American Journal of Medical Science published a paper written by several researchers from Kfar Saba. Their paper got me thinking about how these seemingly separate conditions were often linked. The name Kfar Saba stuck in my mind, and I’ve associated these new tidbits of knowledge with it.

The Kfar Saba paper was the first I had read of the association between vitamin B12 deficiency and autoimmune thyroid disease (AITD). Of the 115 people in the study, all of whom had AITD, 32 of them had low vitamin B12 levels. That’s 28%; just less than one in three. Of those patients who were B12 deficient, 31% had pernicious anemia (Ness-Abramof, 2006). This suggests a solid relationship between vitamin B12 absorption and AITD.

About B12

Absorbing vitamin B12 from food is a challenge; many things can go wrong in the process. As vitamin B12 is pulled out of food in the stomach, proteins secreted in the digestive tract, called salivary R-binders, attach to it. Acid from the stomach and pancreatic proteolytic enzymes are needed to release the B12 from these ‘binders.’ Without them, the B12 will not be absorbed (Marcoullis, 1980).

Once free of the R-binders, B12 is latched onto by B12 intrinsic factor. If this doesn’t happen, B12 will not be absorbed through the intestine into the blood. The vitamin B12 and intrinsic factor complex can only be absorbed through the terminal ileum. B12 deficiency can lead to megaloblastic anemia. On a complete blood count, the Mean Corpuscular Volume (MCV) increases and the RBC count decreases. The most common cause of B12 deficiency is atrophic gastritis, a condition that damages the parietal cells, preventing them from making intrinsic factor, leading to pernicious anemia.

Atrophic gastritis is typically the result of an autoimmune process in which the immune system inappropriately attacks the parietal cells or intrinsic factor itself. Approximately 90% of individuals with pernicious anemia have antibodies for parietal cells; however, only 50% of individuals with these antibodies have pernicious anemia.

The Tie Between AITD, B12 and Iron

This Kfar Saba study was not the first to report an association between AITD and B12 deficiency. An Italian study, published in the Archives of Internal Medicine in 1999, reported that 22 out of 62 AITD patients had confirmed atrophic gastritis. Antiparietal cell antibodies were found in 68% (15/22) of patients with atrophic gastritis. Anemia was observed in 82% (18/22) of patients with AITD and atrophic gastritis. It was not just macrocytic anemia, AITD patients also had a higher incidence of iron deficiency anemia (Centanni, 1999).

Autoimmune gastritis causes atrophic gastritis, which causes about one-quarter of all cases of chronic iron-deficiency anemia. Since the destruction of the parietal cells stops acid production in the stomach and acid is needed to absorb iron, atrophic gastritis can trigger both iron deficiency and B12 deficiency (Hershko, 2007).

This complicates things. As we know, iron deficiency causes microcytic anemia, and the MCV decreases. If B12 and iron deficiencies coexist, the combined increased MCV caused by B12 deficiency and the decreased MCV caused by iron deficiency cancel each other out; the MCV may look normal. The only hint on the CBC may be a larger RDW.

Of course, other conditions besides autoimmune attack can cause atrophic gastritis. The first that comes to mind is Helicobacter pylori. In fact, these infections may be a more common cause of atrophic gastritis than we initially thought.

H. pylori infections cause about one-quarter of all cases of atrophic gastritis (Annibale, 1997). Treating and curing the H. pylori infection will usually improve the damaged tissue, but not always. One study showed reduction in tissue damage in only about half of patients cured of H. pylori infection (Annibale, 2000).

Complicating matters more is that several diseases appear to be closely related. AITD is not a lone entity. One in four people who make antibodies that attack their thyroid also make antibodies that attack the parietal glands, and this can cause B12 and iron deficiency. It probably also lowers calcium absorption. And then there is celiac disease. People with celiac disease have a higher-than normal incidence of AITD, about twice the expected. It works both ways; people with thyroid disease are also more likely to have celiac disease (Hadithi, 2007). Celiac disease also increases risk of B12 deficiency. In one study, 12% of celiac patients were B12 deficient (Dickey, 2002).

There are two possible explanations for this increase. First, celiac disease damages the terminal ileum where B12 is absorbed. Second, celiac disease patients may make antibodies against parietal cells and so cause atrophic gastritis. Although about 10% of the B12-deficient celiac patients have atrophic damage in the stomach and perhaps it is celiac-triggered atrophic gastritis, the current opinion is this relationship is not autoimmune triggered (Dickey, 2002).

A 2005 study looked at 150 patients with chronic, unexplained iron deficiency anemia. Eight (5%) of the patients had celiac disease. Forty (27%) had autoimmune atrophic gastritis, of whom 22 also had low serum vitamin B12 levels. Of the entire 150 patients, 29 (19%) only had H. pylori infection. But, H. pylori infection co-existed along with one of these other causes in 77 people (51%). None of the patients with celiac disease responded or improved with iron supplements. Most of the patients with autoimmune atrophic gastritis (71%) also failed to respond. About the same lack of response (68%) was seen with H. pylori infection. But of the patients who tested negative for these three conditions (AITD, H. Pylori and celiac), almost all (89%) responded to iron supplements. Killing off the H. pylori improved the response to iron supplements (Hershko, 2005).

An Italian study done in 2005 did not observe a relationship between AITD and H. Pylori infection (Tomasi, 2005).
The primary complaint of people with iron deficiency, B12 deficiency anemia or low thyroid function is the same. All three conditions cause fatigue. Vitamin B12 deficiency may also present with neurologic symptoms, typically peripheral glove and stocking numbness or neuropathy. H. pylori infection presents with upper GI symptoms. Celiac disease is traditionally associated with digestive complaints, most commonly chronic diarrhea. This has shifted, however, and it is now believed that digestive complaints are not that common in celiac, occurring in less than 20% of patients. Osteopenia and osteoporosis are common in celiac patients. The explanation typically given is that this results from chronic malabsorption of calcium. It may also be a result of low vitamin B12 levels that lead to increased homocysteine levels, which are linked to osteoporosis.

Atrophic gastritis may present with the kind of complaints we associate with hypochlorhydria. In fact, hypothyroid patients often tell us they benefit from taking betaine hydrochloride. This is a strong hint that atrophic gastritis is present.


The theory that these conditions are linked by the common denominator of autoimmunity ties everything together nicely, but it may not be true. An article published in May 2008 is making me rethink this business all over.

Jabbar at the Aga Khan University in Karachi, Pakistan evaluated 116 hypothyroid patients at his clinic for vitamin B12 deficiency using the standard blood serum test. Forty-six (39.6%) of the patients had low vitamin B12 levels.

In his data, the presence of antithyroid antibodies was not an indicator of B12 deficiency risk. In the earlier Kfar Saba paper, the researchers only looked at people with AITD. In this study, pretty much the same percentage of patients with positive antibodies was B12 deficient (43.2%) as those with negative antibodies (38.9%).

Something else stands out in this study. Without testing their blood for B12 levels, it was hard to distinguish which patients were deficient. The classic signs and symptoms we expect to see with B12 deficiency were little help in identifying affected individuals.

“Generalized weakness, impaired memory, depression, numbness and decreased reflexes were more frequently noted in B12-deficient patients, but failed to achieve statistical significance when compared with B12-sufficient patients.”

MCV, long considered a prime indicator of B12 deficiency, did not differ between groups. Nor were the B12 deficient patients more likely to be anemic. Of the 116 people in the study, 21 complained of symptoms that sounded like B12-deficiency, but their lab test came back normal. They were also given vitamin B12 injections, and 40% of them responded positively. The authors explain this improvement as a placebo response. Our experience suggests that a percentage of people appreciate having higher serum levels of B12 and feel better with treatment even if they test in the normal range.

As tidy a theory as this autoimmunity idea is, it may be wrong or at least not true in all cases.

Tolle Causam

These recently reported associations add complexity to patients who present with hypothyroid disease, anemia or even just fatigue. Our tendency is to diagnose one of these conditions and figure we have done our job but, in fact, all three conditions coexist in patients far more often than we suspect.

We need vigilance in all cases of hypothyroidism, not just watching for symptoms of anemia but testing for coexistent vitamin B12 and iron deficiency. Atrophic gastritis, of either autoimmune or infectious origin, can cause both iron and B12 deficiency, and there is no reason that both deficiencies cannot occur at the same time in the same person. Somewhere between one-third to two-fifths of our low-thyroid patients are probably B12 deficient. We need to test B12 levels in this patient population, and probably iron as well.

Patients on thyroid supplementation frequently still complain of fatigue. It is easy to assume that they are taking insufficient thyroid hormone and send them home with a larger dose of thyroid.

In recent years it has been popular to explain this continuing fatigue as due to inadequate conversion of T4 to T3. So we often experiment, switching the complainers to various combinations of T4 and T3. Yet a 2004 paper by Siegmund et al. comparing duo thyroid hormone therapies against traditional T4 monotherapy tells us that these efforts may be wasting our patients’ time: “Replacement therapy of hypothyroidism with T4 plus T3 does not improve mood and cognitive performance compared to the standard T4 monotherapy. There is even a higher risk of signs of subclinical hyperthyroidism associated with impaired well-being of the patients, which is clearly caused by significant fluctuations in the steady-state fT3 serum concentrations.”

Or, we explain to our patients that their ongoing fatigue is due to their adrenal glands and start long, slow courses of treatment. The odds are high that these non-responders have B12 and/or iron deficiency.

These Kfar Saba people have it bad. They are really tired. You will fight the urge to yawn the moment they walk into the room. Don’t let their fatigue lull you into forgetting this. Try to recall that weird name, Kfar Saba, which I use for the triad of conditions. Remember that in the really tired people, hypothyroidism, iron deficiency and B12 deficiency can all be present. Kfar Saba, the Village of the Grandfathers, think of tired grandfathers, very, very tired grandfathers. Maybe the name will stick.

SchorJacob Schor, ND, FABNO is a 1991 graduate of NCNM and has practiced in Denver for the past 17 years. He served as president of the CANP from 1992 to 1999. He has served on the board of directors of the OncANP since 2006 and currently acts as secretary to the board. He is a Fellow of the ABNO. He was utterly shocked and humbled at the 2008 convention of the AANP to be presented with the Vis Award, an honor bestowed in the memory of William Mitchell. He is incredibly lucky to practice with his wife, Rena Bloom, ND. Dr. Schor writes newsletters for his patients that are popular with doctors and students.

Annibale B et al: Atrophic body gastritis: distinct features associated with Helicobacter pylori infection Helicobacter Jun;2(2):57-64, 1997.

Annibale B et al: Cure of Helicobacter pylori infection in atrophic body gastritis patients does not improve mucosal atrophy but reduces hypergastrinemia and its related effects on body ECL-cell hyperplasia, Aliment Pharmacol Ther May 14(5):625-634, 2000.

Centanni M et al: Atrophic body gastritis in patients with autoimmune thyroid disease: an underdiagnosed association, Arch Intern Med Aug 9-23;159(15):1726-30, 1999.

Dickey W: Low serum vitamin B12 is common in celiac disease and is not due to autoimmune gastritis, Eur J
Gastroenterol Hepatol Apr;14(4):425-7, 2002.

Siegmund W et al: Replacement therapy with levothyroxine plus triiodothyronine (bioavailable molar ratio 14:1) is not superior to thyroxine alone to improve well-being and cognitive performance in hypothyroidism, Clin Endocrinol Jun;60(6):750-757, 2004.

Hadithi M et al: Coeliac disease in Dutch patients with Hashimoto’s thyroiditis and vice versa, World J
Gastroenterol Mar 21;13(11):1715-22, 2007.

Hershko C et al: The anemia of achylia gastrica revisited, Blood Cells Mol Dis Sep-Oct;39(2):178-83, 2007.

Hershko et al: Role of autoimmune gastritis, Helicobacter pylori and celiac disease in refractory or unexplained iron deficiency, Haematologica May;90(5):585-95, 2005.

Jabbar A et al: Vitamin B12 deficiency common in primary hypothyroidism, J Pak Med Assoc. May;58(5):258-261,2008.

Marcoullis G et al: Cobalamin malabsorption due to nondegradation of R proteins in the human intestine. Inhibited cobalamin absorption in exocrine pancreatic dysfunction, J Clin Invest Sep;66(3):430-40, 1980.

Ness-Abramof R et al: Prevalence and evaluation of B12 deficiency in patients with autoimmune thyroid disease, Am J Med Sci Sep;332(3):119-22, 2006.

Tomasi PA et al: Is there anything to the reported association between Helicobacter pylori infection and autoimmune thyroiditis?, Dig Dis Sci Feb;50(2):385-8, 2005.

Recommended Posts

Start typing and press Enter to search