Book Review: Naturopathy Around the World
Stacie Deyglio, ND
Naturopathy Around the World
A unique text, Naturopathy Around the World represents the first effort to present a clear social, historical, and ethnographic report of the naturopathic profession, chiefly as it exists within the United States, Canada, and Australia but also including Germany, Britain, New Zealand, and India. Coauthors Hans A. Baer and Stephen Sporn have integrated a joint endeavor generated from the perspective of an anthropologist with a specialty interest in medical pluralism and of a physician “elder” with long-standing practice and experience in naturopathic politics.
Naturopathy emerged in the United States in the early 20th century under the leadership of Benedict Lust. Since then, “biomedicine came to exert a dominant status over heterodox and folk medical practices” (p xv) as a national medical system of allopathic medicine. This “dominant status” on the part of biomedicine permeates today, with the profession of naturopathy under threat of being co-opted, diluted, extinguished, or willfully assimilated, depending on which viewpoint is being evaluated. The authors evaluate all these perspectives and delve into the historical developments that have shaped the profession, assessing the large medical system and the sociopolitical framework within which naturopathy is embedded. They write:
[D]espite the fact that alternative medical systems may over time achieve a certain semblance of legitimacy and professionalism in the form of licensure laws, statutory registration, governmental support for training and research programs, popularity on the part of the general public, and media coverage, these gains entail the growing accommodation of alternative practitioners to a reductionist theory…. Unless they are part of a major societal transformation, alternative medical systems must accommodate themselves…if they are to survive and prosper. (p xvi)
Outside of the United States, Naturopathy Around the World addresses the historical and ethnographic description of naturopathy in other Western societies, namely, Canada, Britain, Australia, New Zealand, and Germany. There is also a short course of naturopathy as it exists in India.
Given that medical historians and social scientists generate or have generated a fair amount of literature on the other professionalized systems of osteopathy, chiropractic, and homeopathy, little information of this nature exists for the profession of naturopathy. Naturopathy Around the World is the first book of its kind to present such facts and data. It is a useful and purposeful investment for the profession to generate discussion, dialogue, and debate. We must understand the historical past and the pluralistic system we are currently living in to create decisions that will affect the future of the profession of naturopathy.
Table of Contents
Chapter 1: The Rise and Decline of U.S. Naturopathy in the United States Prior to the 1970s
Chapter 2: The Rejuvenation of U.S. Naturopathic Medicine in the Context of the Holistic Health Movement
Chapter 3: The Challenge of the Partially-Professionalized Naturopaths to the Graduates of the Four-Year Naturopathic Colleges in the United States
Chapter 4: Naturopathic Practice and Therapeutics—the Clinical Setting
Chapter 5: The Making, Clinical Practice, and Political Involvement of “America’s Most Beloved Naturopathic Physician”: Stephen’s Story
Chapter 6: Naturopathy in Canada
Chapter 7: Naturopathy Down-under: The Australian Scenario
Chapter 8: Naturopathy in Other Countries: Britain, New Zealand, India, and Germany
Chapter 9: Naturopathy and its Relationship to Medical Systems
- Title: Naturopathy Around the World: Variations and Political Dilemmas of an Eclectic Heterdox Medical System
- Author: Hans A. Baer and Stephen Sporn, ND
- Publisher: Nova Science Publishers, Inc.
- Available from: http://www.novapublishers.com
- Pages: 147
- Style: Hardcover
- Copyright: 2009
- MSRP: $87
Stacie Deyglio, ND received her baccalaureate degree in biology with a minor in chemistry from the College of Mt. St. Vincent in New York. Her personal health issues paved the way to discovering naturopathic medicine in 1999. Resonating with the philosophy and principles of naturopathic medicine, Dr. Deyglio graduated from the University of Bridgeport, College of Naturopathic Medicine in 2003. As a medical student, she was involved in student government, fundraising and the generation of two successful student-run health fairs. Dr. Deyglio’s interests include relating integrative therapeutics to the health of pediatric and geriatric populations. Currently residing in Phoenix, Dr. Deyglio is an avid bookworm, and is actively creating her practice.